Thursday, August 24, 2023

The Personal Librarian

by Marie Benedict and Victoria Christopher Murray

Louise's copy paperback 324 pages plus historical note and authors' notes

Published: 2021

Genre: historical fiction

 

Interesting that I like historical fiction and I love libraries, but I didn't care much for this book. I definitely learned some new things, though! Belle Marion Greener was raised by Richard Greener (first Black graduate of Harvard and an activist for equal rights) and Genevieve Ida Fleet ( a member of a prominent Black DC family). Her parents separated when Belle was a teen and her mother chose to raise the family as white, since they were light-skinned enough and she saw the horrors of racial discrimination. Thus, the young lady became "Belle da Costa Greene" and her skin tone was attributed to fictional Portugese ancestors. She became J.P. Morgan's personal librarian and built a renowned collection of books and artifacts.

 

Page 19: "But the time for hope is past; things are only going to get worse. There is only black and white - nothing in between - and they will always be separate, but never equal. Segregation will take care of that."

 

This is part of a fight between Belle's parents before they split. They had huge ideological differences on how to best navigate life in America in 1905. I learned that the Supreme Court overturned the Civil Rights Act in 1890 . . . it's sad to think of what could have happened (in a positive way) if the politicians of the day hadn't fought to protect the status quo. 


Page 121: But I could not have guessed London's greatest gift. Here, as I walk the streets, I don't feel the same assessment of my color that I routinely experience, and constantly anticipate, in America. Perhaps London's citizens don't have the same need to categorize us by race as they do in America.


I thought that was a very interesting observation. Also the next one.


Page 133: His eyebrows furrow. 'Because he's a Jew,' he spits in a tone that I've heard from him before. 'Or is rumored to be one anyway, though that is not what Berenson claims.' Inside, I sigh. Anti-Semitism is as rampant as racism against the colored in this country.


This makes me sad. People hating people because of skin color, religion, etc. makes our world more difficult.


Page 139: . . . a glimmering shade almost like grisaille . . . 

 

 A word I've never seen before! I knew it was a color, but I had to look it up. Dictionary.com says:

a method of painting in gray monochrome, typically to imitate sculpture.
"trompe l'oeil elevations painted in grisaille"
 
So it's more of a painting technique than a color. The guy had gray eyes that looked like sculpture? Okay.
 
 
 
Page 176: "Not that I'm concerned, of course. Because no matter who you see or what you do, you are my personal librarian. You must always remember that you belong to me."
 
 
It's historical fiction, but I can imagine someone like J.P. Morgan saying something like this!  How awful for a black woman passing as white to hear her boss say that he OWNS her. Yuk.

 
Page 207 broke my heart. I didn't like her romance with the older, married Bernard Berenson. But when she got pregnant and he urged an abortion and then wasn't there with her! That was too much. She was physically, mentally, and emotionally broken. (This may or may not have happened in real life. Greene destroyed all her personal papers before she died.)

 
Page 288: We shared an insatiable curiosity. The deeper we each read, the more we would understand about this world we live in, and the more questions we had.

 
This resonated for me. I love reading. I love learning. I'm a tiny bit curious to learn more about J.P. Morgan, but that can wait for another day. I'm glad I read about this woman - a real librarian, a strong woman, a person who made a difference. (I looked up the Morgan Library. That would be an amazing place to visit!)
 

Theodore Roosevelt, Hero to His Valet

by James E. Amos

University of Minnesota Library hardcover 162 pages

Published: 1927

Genre: non-fiction biography


Oh. my. word. Where to start?!


I read about this somewhere else (don't remember!) and was curious. Teddy Roosevelt is one of the U.S. presidents I really like. I appreciate that he set aside National Parks for us! Especially since the railroad and timber barons were so powerful at the time.


This book was published the year my mom was born! There's a nameplate inside the front cover saying it was donated from the collection of O.M. Leland (dean emeritus) of the Institute of Technology (1921-1944) and his signature from July 1931! It's just a cool piece of history.


For the book itself, of course Amos is going to have an incredibly positive view of TR. As he tells of how he came to work for the president, he seems to be a wonderful man himself. He was only in his young twenties when he was hired to look after the Roosevelt children. Through his service to the family, he was proximal to President Roosevelt and worked for him for many years. 


Page 8-9: Mr. Roosevelt was not only my employer, but he was until his death my dear friend to whom I could go always with my most personal and private troubles. I loved him deeply and served him, I hope, faithfully. And I have always liked to believe that he rather took a fancy to me at that very first meeting. That would be his way. Mr. Roosevelt's disposition was to like people. He never approached men with suspicion in his mind. He was always disposed to believe that people were all right and he liked those he met if they gave him half a chance.


I love the way Amos tells his stories; it's almost as though he and the reader are just chatting. It was also bizarre to picture what the White House was like just over 100 years ago . . . I'm guessing that in the last few decades, there are hundreds (if not thousands?) more employees!


Page 10: At first people used to swarm into the White House. The President's working quarters were there and altogether the little privacy the home part of the building enjoyed was subject to many interruptions. Under Mr. Roosevelt this was all changed. No President was as approachable as he was. He saw more people, probably, than any Chief Executive in our history. But he drew a line around that portion of the mansion which was called home, and he managed to keep his boys and girls living in a perfectly natural atmosphere in spite of the turbulent and stormy official life that swarmed all around them.


There are some fantastic photographs in the book. The picture of the author doesn't appear to show a black man, but later he refers to "his race." I looked him up online and found that yes, Amos was African American. The picture of the Roosevelt family shows the four boys and one daughter with the President, his wife, and their dog Skip. 


Page 15: Public men are subject to all sorts of bitter criticism and if they filed suits against all the people who libeled them they would spend all their days in court. . . . 


He had an "Ananias Club" to assign people who lied about him! It's one of those Bible stories that makes me stop and think about God's message about lying. I'm not surprised that part of being in the public eye is dealing with what people say about you, but I think it's interesting that there were two times Roosevelt charged people with libel. And that he started his "Ananias Club!"


Page 25: It was orders from home - from Mrs. Roosevelt - that whenever Mr. Roosevelt was traveling he must have one hour of absolute quiet during the day. He was a man of such tremendous energy that he would keep going forever if there was not someone around to slow him down. That was part of my job on all trips. . . . He preached the 'strenuous life.' But he also knew the value of the 'quiet hour.'


Reading this makes me curious to learn more about Mrs. Roosevelt! It is wise indeed to have some quiet time each day. In another chapter, Amos talks about some of the leading figures of the day and Mr. Roosevelt's relationship with them. I was surprised in this part about Booker T. Washington. (This is what I love about reading books like this - I learn new things!)


Page 56: . . . it is sometimes the little things that mar the effects of a man's work. And the fact that he preached to his race to send their children to manual training schools to learn to be good servants and workers, and then sent his son to England and his daughter to Wellesley to be educated, brought a good deal of criticism down on him from his own people.

 

Amos reprints a "wall motto" that was hanging at President Roosevelt's desk before he left the White House. It is "Opportunity" by John James Ingalls.

Master of human destinies am I;
Fame, love and fortune on my footsteps wait.
Cities and fields I walk. I penetrate
Deserts and seas remote, and, passing by
Hovel and mart and palace, soon or late,
I knock unbidden once at every gate.

If sleeping, wake; if feasting, rise, before
I turn away. It is the hour of fate,
And they who follow me reach every state
Mortals desire, and conquer every foe
Save death; but those who hesitate
Condemned to failure, penury and woe,
Seek me in vain, and uselessly implore.
I answer not, and I return no more.


I don't really like this poem, but the fact that it was meaningful to Roosevelt is interesting to me. It was most sad to me that Roosevelt grieved deeply for his youngest son, Quentin, who was shot down in France in July 1918. Theodore died six months later.


Page 158-159: But there was one disaster that I have always felt was too much even for his brave heart - that was the death of his son Quentin, whom we all loved. Quentin was shot down in an aeroplane while flying over the German lines.


Amos goes on to share about the change in Mr. Roosevelt's demeanor and his deep sadness. This is a lovely little book and I'm glad I read it!

Friday, August 18, 2023

Because of the Rabbit

by: Cynthia Lord

Libby audiobook 3 hours

Read by: Kate Reinders

Published: 2019

Genre: childen's realistic fiction


This was sweet, but clearly for an elementary age reader (interesting that I enjoy middle grades fiction so much!). Emma helps her game warden dad rescue a rabbit one evening. This is no wild animal; it's a pet! Holding it overnight to take to the shelter in the morning, Emma falls in love. 

 

Oh, and Emma is going to public school for the first time after having been home schooled.


This is a story about fitting in and standing out. It's about kids and relationships and meanness and friendship. It's sweet but not terribly memorable.

Murder in the Mystery Suite

by: Ellery Adams

Libby audiobook 9 hours

Read by: Johanna Parker

Published: 2014

Genre: murder mystery


When I "opened" this book to listen, it was on chapter 3. Apparently, I tried this once before and returned it unread and unblogged. This time I listened to the end. There were things I liked and things I disliked.


Here's the description that caught my attention (twice):

Tucked away in the rolling hills of rural western Virginia is the storybook resort of Storyton Hall, catering to book lovers who want to get away from it all. To increase her number of bookings, resort manager Jane Steward has decided to host a Murder and Mayhem week so that fans of the mystery genre can gather together for some role-playing and fantasy crime solving.

But when the winner of the scavenger hunt, Felix Hampden, is found dead in the Mystery Suite, and the valuable book he won as his prize is missing, Jane realizes one of her guests is an actual murderer. Amid a resort full of fake detectives, Jane is bound and determined to find a real-life killer. There’s no room for error as Jane tries to unlock this mystery before another vacancy opens up…

 

I liked the literary allusions! There were lots and lots and lots of references and some I didn't know. I liked that there were so many clues and twists.


Jane's twin sons were named Fitzgerald and Hemingway. Fun!

 

I like that so many of the guests thoroughly enjoyed the Murder and Mayhem activities and it benefited other businesses in the small town. It was fun to think that Jane would plan other theme weeks for Storyton Hall.


I didn't like "Mrs. Pratt" - she was probably why I stopped reading it the first time. She just seemed creepy. I'm not sure what her age was, but she came across as a middle aged sex-starved pervert. Yuk.

 

Aunt Octavia is sickening with her disregard for her own health (overeating and not exercising), especially considering her extreme concern for the big family secret.

 

Also, Aunt Octavia is spending money on extravagant clothes when Storyton is falling into disrepair and money is needed to take care of the building? What the heck!

 

The bend-over-backwards-to-appease the guests by Jane is absolutely mind-boggling. This was clearly written before the era of shaming Karen behaviors.


I didn't like how extreme the story got - they have a secret, hidden library that has untold treasures (like the fabled library at Alexandria). The Stewards are literal stewards of this treasure and Jane is now going to train to be a superhero of sorts. It just got to be a bit much.

Sunday, August 06, 2023

I Am the Messenger

by Markus Zusak

Libby audiobook 9 hours

Read by: Marc Aden Gray

Published: 2002 (this version 2006)

Genre: YA realistic fiction with fantasy elements


Wow. This was both bizarre and incredible. I think I remember getting this for PRMS, based purely on the popularity of The Book Thief. Well this book is NOT really for a typical middle school reader. It isn't just the swearing, violence, drinking, etc. that make it for an older reader; it's the deeply philosophical look at the meaning of life. 


I just googled the author because the book (and the reader's accent) most definitely indicated Australia as the location of the story. Yes. 


Here's Wikipedia's intro to the book: "The protagonist is Ed Kennedy, an uninspired 19-year old Australian taxi driver. Ed laments his mediocre life and strained relationship with his mother, as his father died recently and left Ed with only his dog, the Doorman, but does nothing to improve his situation, instead preferring to continue living alone and playing cards every week with his friends: Ritchie, who is unemployed and generally apathetic about life; Marv, a stingy carpenter; and Audrey, a fellow taxi driver whom Ed is in love with, although she does not reciprocate. After accidentally foiling a robbery he is proclaimed a hero by the public, though the robber leaves him a warning that he sees "a dead man" when he looks at Ed before being taken away by police. One night, he receives a small unmarked envelope, inside of which is an Ace of Diamonds with three addresses and times of day written on them. His friends deny involvement, so Ed investigates the three addresses."

 

 "Beautiful women are the torment of my existence." - Ed, such a genuine, honest character.


Audrey, Marv, Ritchie, . . . Mila, Sophie, so many others . . . why the violence? 


Playing cards - hearts last. Diamonds - 3 addresses. Clubs - names on rocks. (Beatings to start and finish.) Spades - authors / street names / family with Christmas lights. Hearts - friends.


The Doorman! Stinky dog, sweet friend. Conversations! Sharing coffee.


Conversation with his mom. Loss of his dad.


"Sometimes I wish I was a dog." - me, too, Ed. Me, too.

 

 

Saturday, July 29, 2023

Code Name Edelweiss

by Stephanie Landsem

Dakota County Library paperback 398 pages plus author's note

Published: 2023

Genre: Christian historical fiction

 

I didn't even wait until I finished the book to see how much of this was historically accurate! I also went online to read about the movie Mad Dog of Europe. I can't believe it was never finished! I'd love to see what was filmed in the 1930s. Fascinating stuff. Finding out that Landsem is a Minnesota author took me to her webpage. It would be so cool to talk with her about her book! Book Club meets in two days, so . . . probably not going to happen.


Liesl Weiss is a German woman raising her two children with her mother's help ever since her husband simply didn't come home from work one day two years previously. She is abruptly let go from her job as a secretary at MGM Studios and desperate to find a job to support the family. She is hired by Leon Lewis to spy on the German nationalists in Los Angeles. I'm not doing the story justice! It is so incredibly well-written. I'll just start with my post-it notes.


Page 37 - "With a pang of guilt, I caught the trolley and turned my mind to finding work instead of the unrelenting questions of motherhood."


Liesl is trying to be a 1930s supermom. She's working to support the family, trying to establish limits and discipline, be nurturing and supportive, and hope earnestly that her husband will show up. The "unrelenting questions" of motherhood have plagued many women!


Page 79 - "I pulled the covers up to her chin and kissed her brow, wondering how to talk to a child about people like the Grundbachers."


Liesl's daughter Tess has been told by her Aryan classmates that she should not play with Frieda because she's Jewish and "Jews are dirty and have germs." Sadly, parents teaching their children prejudice, hatred, and racism is an evil that still happens today. It can be hard as a parent to figure out how to teach your children to respond to this. Liesl's answer was pretty lame, in my opinion. "Jesus did not have germs. Go to sleep now." Waiting until she's older isn't sufficient!


Page 85 - "Somebody needed to tell those kids the real enemies weren't the Jews or the Catholics or Negroes, like the Klan and the National Socialists wanted them to believe. The real enemies were poverty and injustice and ignorance - and hate."

 

Wilhelm was my favorite character! I love that he really cared about the young men being recruited by the Nazis.


Page 103 - "Vati had taught me that being German was something to be proud of - a culture that valued work and orderliness, love for family and duty to country."


I love how the author made Liesl such a relatable character. She took the job with Leon Lewis just to have some income. She was convinced that working at the German American headquarters will not lead to any spy-worthy information. After being given a copy of Mein Kampf, her reading leads her to question her assumptions. 


Page 178 - "'But it is easier to turn a blind eye.' He tipped his head to the crowd of men hoping for a day's work. 'Especially when you have troubles of your own.'"


During this era in history, people were more concerned about economics, jobs, etc. They were past the "Great War" and not thinking so much about geopolitical events.


Page 192 - "'You don't have nothing to be sorry for,' she said. 'It's the way of the world.'"


A black woman with her two children says this to Liesl after Liesl apologizes that the woman was refused service at a restaurant. Her resignation that this is just the way of the world is so sad to me.


Page 210 - "He looked back at me and for a moment, I saw a flash of the boy I'd known. 'I love you too.'"


Oh! I love this scene between Liesl and her brother Fritz! She has been so frustrated by his choices in life and his becoming a Nazi. When she talks with him and reminds him that she loves him, I think it's a turning point for him.


Page 301 - "He was just a kid and kids shouldn't die. When they did, your heart died with them. And then you lived the rest of your life with a big hole in your chest."


I can't imagine losing a child! The fear that Liesl and Miriam feel for their children is palpable. Evil people doing evil things . . . and the innocent suffer.


Page 387 - "Our lives had been a mixture of struggles and joy but Tomas had loved me through the quarrels and our differences. I knew that now. I had not been abandoned. Not by Tomas and not by God."


It was so awful to find out what really happened to Tomas! I can't imagine the guilt of thinking he'd left her because he didn't even love her. As she explains to Tess and little Steffen, she recognizes that she has grown in her faith.


Author's Note - "Then there was what was happening in our own time in the United States. The years between 2016 and 2020 were ones of increasing division in our country. Families split along political lines. Our partisan government bickered instead of leading. The media lost credibility. Starting in 2020, a global pandemic created fear, peaceful protests turned violent, and mob mentality destroyed cities. Every part of our society struggled with isolation, distrust, and division. I began to see more clearly what might have happened during the privations of the Great Depression, the tragedy of the Dust Bowl, and the heightened racial tensions of the 1930s."


She is so eloquent! I really like this author.


Historical Note - "This is what I hope you gain from Liesl and Wilhelm's story: the truth about courage, conviction, and love that both encompasses and transcends the historical record."


Yes and amen. I loved that the theme of "If not me, who? If not now, when?" ran throughout the book. I also liked that the idea of love overcoming fear and hate is an idea that we can put into practice.


I look forward to this book discussion on Monday!



Enola Holmes and the Boy in Buttons (Enola Holmes #8)

by Nancy Springer

Libby audiobook 32 minutes

Read by: Tamaryn Payne

Published: 2021

Genre: YA historical detective mystery

 

I've read several Enola Holmes mysteries. This novella is delightful. Enola's helper (the boy in buttons) is sick one day and so his little brother comes in his stead. The younger brother doesn't come back home and Enola goes to find him. 

 

Short and satisfying. I enjoyed it and may get back into reading this series.

The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle

by Stuart Turton

Libby audiobook 17 hours

Read by James Cameron Stewart

Published: 2018

Genre: murder mystery with a fantasy twist


I'm not sure how to write about this book. It was strange. And pretty violent. But I was curious to find out the "whodunnit" aspect and so I finished the whole book. 


From Amazon: "The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle is a breathlessly addictive mystery that follows one man's race to find a killer, with an astonishing time-turning twist that means nothing and no one are quite what they seem. Aiden Bishop knows the rules. Evelyn Hardcastle will die every day until he can identify her killer and break the cycle. But every time the day begins again, Aiden wakes up in the body of a different guest at Blackheath Manor. And some of his hosts are more helpful than others. With a locked-room mystery that Agatha Christie would envy, Stuart Turton unfurls a breakneck novel of intrigue and suspense."

 

What I liked: the clues, the intellectual challenge of trying to figure out who was the murderer, Aiden as a character

 

What I disliked: the odd illogic / impossibility of living within several "hosts" and repeating the same day multiple times, the creepiness of the Footman and his psycho love of causing pain, the too numerous characters to the point of not even trying to figure out who's who, the fact that I was sucked in and completed a 17 hour audiobook!

Monday, July 24, 2023

How to Win Friends and Influence People: Updated for the Next Generation of Leaders

by Dale Carnegie

Libby audiobook 8 hours

Read by: Robert Petkoff

Genre: Non-fiction, self-help (of a sort)

 

I was curious about this book because it's one I've heard of for over four decades. I finally requested it and after a long waiting period, got it to listen to. There are times I found it interesting and relevant. And then there are times I thought it hasn't been updated nearly enough! Some of the later portions are definitely in an older mindset of workers should always give their best for their workplace . . . and quite frankly, I don't think that all employers deserve their employees' "all" just to increase their own profits. Some of the advice seems to be more about common sense and common courtesy. I like how there are little stories and illustrations for all the points.


Here are the main points I jotted down:

Part One - 

1. Don't criticize, condemn, or complain.

2. Give honest and sincere appreciation.

3. Arouse in the other person an eager want.


Part Two - 

1. Become genuinely interested in other people.

2. Smile.

3. Remember that a person's name is to that person the sweetest and most important sound in any language.

4. Be a good listener. Encourage others to talk about themselves.

5. Talk in terms of the other person's interests.

6. Make the other person feel important and do it sincerely.


Part Three - How to Win People to Your Way of Thinking

1. The only way to get the best of an argument is to avoid it.

2. Show respect for the other person's opinions. Never say "You're wrong."

3. If you're wrong, admit it quickly and emphatically.

4. Begin in a friendly way.

5. Get the other person saying "Yes yes" immediately.

6. Let the other person do a great deal of the talking.

7. Let the other person feel that the idea is his or hers.

8. Try earnestly to see things from the other's POV.

9. Be sympathetic with the other person's ideas and desires.

10. Appeal to the nobler motives.

11. Dramatize your ideas.

12. Throw down a challenge.

 

Part Four - Be a Leader

1. Begin with praise and honest appreciation.

2. Call attention to people's mistakes indirectly.

3. Talk about your own mistakes before criticizing others.

4. Ask questions instead of giving direct orders.

5. Let the other person save face.

6. Praise the slightest improvement and praise every improvement. Be hearty in your approbation and lavish in your praise.

7. Give the other person a fine reputation to live up to.

8. Use encouragement. Make the fault seem easy to correct.

9. Make the person happy about doing the thing you suggest.

 

My favorite part was when he talked about how dogs give unconditional love and attention. I jotted "be like a dog!" :-) 


Being a good listener is the advice I most need to improve upon.


I found a scrap of paper with notes about some quotations I'd like to save here.


"Most folks are as happy as they make up their minds to be." - Abraham Lincoln


"Actions seem to follow feeling, but really actions and feeling go together; and by regulating the action, which is under the more direct control of the will, we can indirectly regulate the feeling, which is not. Thus the sovereign voluntary path to cheerfulness, if our cheerfulness be lost, is to sit up cheerfully and to act and speak as if cheerfulness were already there." - William James


"There is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so." (from Hamlet) - William Shakespeare

 

Girl Forgotten

by April Henry

Libby audiobook 6 hours

read by: Tessa Netting

Published: 2023

Genre: YA murder mystery

 

"Seventeen years ago, Layla Trello was murdered and her killer was never found. Enter true-crime fan Piper Gray, who is determined to re-open Layla's case and get some answers. With the help of Jonas - who has a secret of his own - Piper starts a podcast investigating Layla's murder. But as she digs deeper into the mysteries of the past, Piper begins receiving anonymous threats telling her to back off the investigation, or else."

 

This book bothered me more than I anticipated. I've read other April Henry books and I know I'm not her target audience, but some of the issues raised seem to be too easily dismissed.

 

Podcasting, journalistic integrity, research, innuendo, rumor, inaccurate info, sensationalism, perspective . . . especially when dealing with the true crime genre and real people's lives . . . it just didn't seem to address these questions very well. 

 

The killer was not who I anticipated. I liked Jonas, except for being so upset with Piper for her untruth.  

Wednesday, July 12, 2023

Wish You Were Here

 by: Rita Mae Brown

Libby eBook pagination dependent upon font size

Published: 2004

Genre: realistic fiction plus animal thoughts


A friend recommended this to me when I mentioned how much I enjoyed the animals' point of view in the Chet and Bernie mystery series. I had a hard time getting into this book and seriously thought about returning it unfinished.


The main character is the postmistress "Harry." I don't recall what her real name is and this moniker is from her soon-to-be-ex-husband's last name "Haristeen." I just looked - her name is Mary Minor Haristeen. But everyone calls her "Harry." Her cat Mrs. Murphy and her corgi dog Tucker share their side of the story. Crozet, Virginia is a small town where everybody is in everybody else's business. There were so many characters! It was a bit challenging to figure them out for a while. Oh! And Harry's spouse was named "Pharamond Haristeen" and went by "Fair."


A businessman is found dead in a cement mixer. A businesswoman is found in pieces after being tied to railroad tracks (she was already dead). Harry is snooping for clues and shooting her mouth.


This book wasn't one I'll eagerly read the rest of the series for. I did highlight a few passages, though.


Chapter 1: "What I'm getting at is that maybe we don't know one another as well as we think we do. It's a small-town illusion - thinking we know each other." 

 

Susan and Harry are talking about who the killer might be. 


Chapter 2: "Something had happened to America within Harry's life span, something she couldn't quite put her finger on, but something she could feel, sharply. There was no contest between God and the golden calf. Money was God, these days. Little pieces of green paper with dead people's pictures on them were worshipped. (sic) People no longer killed for love. They killed for money. How odd to be alive in a time of spiritual famine."


This disheartening sentiment is sadly too close to the truth. The author herself isn't particularly spiritual, though. 


Chapter 2: "Heaven was all very fine but you had to die to get there. Harry wasn't afraid to die but she wouldn't refuse to live either."


Harry is reflecting on Mrs. Hogendobber - the characteristically overbearing, obnoxious, self-righteous Christian. Harry observes that she "vainly clung to a belief system that had lost its power."


Chapter 10: "Mom used to say, 'A woman marries a man hoping to change him and a man marries a woman hoping she'll never change.'"


That's an interesting notion. It fit for Harry's marriage.


Chapter 10: "By the time Harry cleaned up the mess she was too tired to discipline them. To her credit, she understood that this was punishment for her leaving. She understood, but was loath to admit that the animals trained her far better than she trained them."


I get this! Animals can be super effective at training their humans. 


Chapter 11 and another chapter had a group of animals talking about how humans don't kill the sick young like animals do. This made sense from the animals' point of view, but was a little concerning . . . at what age do we decide a "sick" person (e.g. a killer) should be put to death? Who decides? 


Chapter 17: "What worried him was the example he set. He didn't want to be a slave to his job but he didn't want to be too lazy either. He didn't want to be too stern but he didn't want to be too lax. He didn't want to treat his son any differently from his daughter but he knew he did."


Ned was a great character, but we didn't see much of him other than disciplining his son for pulling $500 out of Ned's account. 


Toward the end of the book, a character referenced the "War of Northern Aggression," and though I've heard of that name for the Civil War, it's a bit unsettling.


Great Expectations

by Charles Dickens

Libby audiobook 15.5 hours

Read by: Simon Prebble

Published: 1861 (this version 2011)

Genre: realistic (historical) fiction


I can't believe I haven't blogged this before! I taught it to ninth graders back in the 90s. I've read it multiple times, but not in recent years. (I've not yet seen a movie version.)


I'd forgotten some of the details and was delighted to reacquaint myself with "the Aged Parent" and some of the other characters. It's amazing to me how powerfully Dickens can evoke emotions and examine human nature in his characterizations.

 

As always, I start the story being sympathetic to Pip and upset with his sister, Mrs. Gargery. Joe Gargery is a fascinating character, strong, kind, sympathetic. He had an abusive dad and he wanted to protect his mother. He put up with Pip's sister because of the kind of person he was, not because of her merits. He was an illiterate blacksmith who did his best to protect Pip. (I had forgotten what happened to Mrs. G . . . )


"Philip Pirrip" came out of the little boys' mouth as "Pip." I love that name! I had forgotten that Herbert Pocket had given him the nickname of "Handel."


Miss Havisham was her creepy self as I remembered. I had forgotten her grief at realizing what Estella had become.


There were a couple of times that I wasn't sure of what word I heard. I only jotted down one from chapter 8: "farinaceous—having a mealy or powdery texture." (https://nycmsenglish.weebly.com/great-expectations-vocabulary.html)


Some of my favorite parts were when Pip spoke up for Matthew Pocket to Miss Havisham, when Joe came to nurse Pip back to health, and when Herbert rescued him on the marshes.


My least favorite characters were Compeyson, Orlick, and Pumblechook. My favorites were Pip (most of the time), Wemmeck, and Joe. Joe is the best!






Monday, July 10, 2023

Winterborne Home for Mayhem and Mystery

by Ally Carter

Libby audiobook 8 hours

read by: Laura Knight Keating

Published: 2021

Genre: YA mystery, adventure


I didn't enjoy this quite as much as the first Winterborne book, but April, Collin, and the other orphans are firmly attached to Gabriel Winterborne and they strive to "help" him as they seek adventure. Some mysteries and loose ends from the first book are tied up. The island was interesting. The bad guys were really bad.

Friday, June 30, 2023

A Share in Death

by Deborah Crombie

Libby audiobook 7 hours

read by: Michael Deehy

Published: 2006

Genre: Murder mystery


Honestly, this wasn't a very memorable book. I finished it last week and had to read the description to remember what it was about.


Detective Duncan Kincaid is on vacation when a dead body shows up. It's not his jurisdiction, but he is a police officer with Scotland Yard, so . . . the local cops do NOT appreciate his interference in their case. Then another body turns up.


There were SO MANY characters, I couldn't really keep them straight. Lots of flirty stuff and innuendo. It was an okay murder mystery, but not one where I'm eager to find others by this author.

Wednesday, June 21, 2023

A Perfect Mistake

by Melanie Conklin

Libby audiobook 6 hours

Read by: Christopher Gebauer

Published: 2022

Genre: YA realistic fiction

 

I listened to this while at work yesterday. It was okay. Something happened to cause Will to be in a coma. Max is struggling to figure out what really happened when he, Will, and Joey, followed some older boys into the woods in the middle of the night.

 

There were things I liked about this book, but it wasn't overwhelmingly fabulous. The perspective of a kid with ADHD and how he tries to  manage his life was interesting. (I love the idea of OHIO - Only Handle It Once. You could also call this "do it now.")


I liked his relationship with his uncle and the woodworking. I liked Sam (the girl in his class) and how they worked as a team to figure things out.


It was interesting that part of the story dealt with people's perceptions of Max, who was almost six feet tall as an 11 year old sixth grader. There were a lot of perception themes running through this.


The mystery wasn't what I expected. It was okay, but not great.

Not If I Save You First

by Ally Carter

Libby Audiobook 7 hours

Read by: Brittany Pressley

Published: 2018

Genre: YA mystery



This started out well, but was incredibly cringe-worthy by the end. Maddie is the daughter of the head of Secret Service. Logan is the President's son. They are best friends until Russian bad guys try to kidnap Logan's mom and Maddie's dad is shot. Maddie and her dad head to the Alaskan wilderness with no internet connection and minimal human contact for six years. 


I liked the letters from Maddie to Logan. They really helped set the scene for her changing personality and alienation from her best friend. Him going off the rails as a teenager and trying to get away from the Secret Service protection was believable.


When the story veered off into the teenage angst of longing and shallow insecurity, I was already curious to see how the story would turn out, so I listened to the end.


It wasn't very realistic to see the change in the character of Stefan, but I ended up liking him. I liked Maddie when she was tough Alaskan survival girl, but was irritated when she fretted about her hair. How interesting that I liked Carter's story for younger readers (The Winterborne Home for Vengeance and Valor) better than this one for older readers!

Project 1065

by: Alan Gratz

Scott County Library hardcover 303 pages plus author's note

Published: 2016

Genre: YA historical fiction


I read this for two reasons: Gratz books are popular with middle schoolers and I hadn't read one yet AND a class I was subbing in had three historical novels being read and discussed. (A Night Divided by Jennifer Nielsen, Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys, and this one.) It's interesting that two are WWII era and one is Cold War . . . not sure how the teacher addressed that with the class.


I have LOTS of post-it notes and not much time, so I may summarize. I found this book interesting but hard to believe. Michael O'Shaunessey is the son of the Irish ambassador to Germany. Stationed in Berlin, he participates in the Hitler Youth so that he can work as a spy for the Allies. Another boy, Fritz, shares that his dad is working on a secret jet plane "Projekt 1065" and Michael is determined to get the plans to the Allies. (Note: he has a photographic memory and an excellent grasp of German.)


Page 41: "'Compassion is a weakness,' Horst said for the benefit of me and anyone else in our squad who might not like bullies picking on little kids."


Bullies are part of life, but Nazi Germany really allowed them to thrive. How terrifying to have people like this in charge. 


Page 41: "I rose up on an elbow, my Irish blood thundering war drums in my ears, ready to knock Horst's donkey teeth down his throat."


One of my favorite parts of the book was when Michael and a rescued British pilot told jokes and made comments about their cultures and countries. The Irish / English / Scottish humor was amusing. But probably also very stereotyping. I did learn that Ireland stayed neutral during WWII. I love when I learn something new from a novel!


Page 53: "Because that's what Nazi Germany was: the bully who found your most painful wound and poked at it with a stick."


Again with the bullying theme. I wonder if the author was thinking of his middle school readers and the importance of taking a stand against bullying.


Page 92: "There was a haunted look in Simon's eyes now, and I knew he wasn't joking. About any of it. It sounded silly to be afraid of birds, but a real fear, a real phobia, was a serious thing. People without one couldn't understand."


I like that Simon helped Michael overcome his fear of heights (or at least find ways to cope) and that he shared his fear. The compassion and friendship they had was a wonderful part of this book.


Page 103 and 176 . . . the scenes with their "Herr Professor Doktor Major Melcher" were powerful. The theme of life and whose life is most worth saving ran throughout the book. Wow. I should put a screen shot of page 176 here, but I'll just put some excerpts.

"Again I saw myself four years ago, on the Night of Broken Glass. But now I saw it through new eyes - the eyes of my parents. Saw the awful trade: one man's life against the fate of the entire world. My heart ached, as if it were slowly eating me up from inside."

"Sometimes we have to sacrifice good people to win a war, Simon had told me. Sometimes you do what you have to do, even if doing it means doing something wrong."

"Instead, I said nothing. I locked my heart away in a wee iron coffin and swallowed the key. It burned going down and tears stung my eyes, but still I said nothing."


Page 296: "It was a world war, and the fate of every nation on Earth, neutral or not, lay in the balance. When the war was over, the world would be ruled one way, or the other - by freedom or fascism, by hope or by fear. I had seen the depths, the lengths, the Nazis would go to win that war, sacrificing their own children to the cause, and I also knew first-hand the sacrifices the Allies had made to stop them."

 

I will definitely read more Gratz books next school year while subbing. I love that authors can make historical fiction so accessible to young people!





Friday, June 09, 2023

Winterborne Home for Vengeance and Valor

by Ally Carter

Libby audiobook 7 hours

read by: Laura Knight Keating

Published: 2020

Genre: YA mystery

 

I loved this! I was just looking for available audiobooks to listen to while working my summer job. When I looked up this author, I was so surprised to recognize her Gallagher Girls (Spy School) series. 

 

In this book, April is on a field trip to a museum with other foster kids. She sees a box with a design like the one on the key her mother left with her when she was just a baby. Gabriel Winterborne has been missing since his eleventh birthday and a five million dollar reward has been offered for information on his whereabouts. 

 

I love the characters and the unpredictable storyline (other than that good triumphs over evil, of course). I love Collin and the descriptions of the cool old house. I love the butler! I am eager to get hold of the other Winterborne books! 


<Above published 6.9.23. Below added 6.16.25.>


I wanted an audiobook to listen to while driving and was so disappointed in the Octagon Valley book that I decided to re-listen to this one. It's well-written, interesting, and has some interesting elements of identity, foster care, family, etc. Gabriel Winterborne is a swashbuckling guy for sure.

Tuesday, May 30, 2023

The Extraordinary Deaths of Mrs. Kip

By: Sara Brunsvold

Dakota County Library paperback 354 pages plus extras (author's notes, etc.)

Published: 2022

Genre: Christian fiction, historical fiction


Oh! This was so good! I read it all yesterday and am contemplating buying a copy . . . but I won't, since I'm trying to decrease my possessions. I will highly recommend it, though!


Mrs. Kip is a childless widow who goes into hospice after recently being diagnosed with terminal cancer.


Aidyn Kelley is a talented writer who feels stuck in her assistant role at a newspaper.


The story switches between "present day" (2016) and Clara's (Mrs. Kip's) past going from the 1960s to the 1980s. 


Page 27 (May 10, 1969): "She didn't like Scotch either, not like John did. And she hated that ugly chair, which barely fit in her tiny dwelling. And she had long stopped considering their song a pleasant experience. But they were all the material things she had left of her husband. Those three things. All of them empty promises from a happier time when they were both too inexperienced to know what life was capable of."


This was so sad! We learn more about Clara and John and what happened later in the story. But here, she is a young grieving widow. And stuff is just stuff. The theme of grief runs strong in this story. I wonder if my brother would read it.


Page 47/48 (2016): "For the next twenty minutes, she sat in the armchair next to his bed and listened to his stories of work, of his wife, of the other things that brought him joy. She helped him forget he was widowed and dying.

The tender worship of companionship. A hard art to learn."


Oh my! For Clara to be in hospice and extend grace and compassion to her crotchety room neighbor Charles was so sweet! I love that she barged into his life and insisted on becoming his friend. I love that she wasn't put off by his rudeness but knew that he needed some friendship. She saw through his exterior to the sadness and loneliness within. 


Page 114 (2016): "Clara smiled, feeling the lightness in her heart - that sensation of the Lord's hand at work, orchestrating his people to be part of a generous answer to prayer."


Clara and Rosario are talking about "hidden warriors" and specifically Aidyn's editor Bella Woods. I love the way we can be receptive to seeing God at work. He's at work whether we're cognizant of it or not! This is reminiscent of the Godwinks books a little . . . watch for the ways God is at work in our lives!


Page 159 (July 1, 1975): "These were the very same men who bravely risked everything to help the US fight in exchange for the promise of protection and reward. A gentlemen's agreement had brought Mahasajun and Mai to specialized training in the first place. But with President Ford's sudden order to withdraw from Laos, the US effectively reneged and abandoned the people to face the consequences of their allegiance. Alone and unarmed. The news reports had not been pretty."


Actions have consequences. People act as though politics and international relations should just be done a certain way and everything would turn out fine. But there are typically so many angles and aspects . . . and human lives that are dramatically affected by the decisions made by others. I was a little kid in 1975. I just wanted to play, read, watch cartoons, and eat yummy food. But what is happening now in 2023 that I'm not paying attention to?


Page 164 (2016): "You are precious. Do you hear me? You are seen. You are known. You are longed for. Do you believe that? . . . So long as we have breath, the Lord calls to our hearts."


Clara is talking to Charles, who is unresponsive and near death. Her desire to share salvation with him is impressive. I love her as a character! She is an inspiration. This may be my favorite scene in the book.


Page 193 (2016): "'When things like that happen, you need friends, Miss Kelley. You need the Lord more than anything, but in his benevolence, he often shows up in the form of friends. Like Jonathan for David in the Bible.'"


I love all of Clara's life advice to Aidyn, but this passage led to her sharing about her friend Martha getting her to go to counseling after nine years of grieving John's sudden death (when they were only 23 and had been married only 8 months!). Friendship matters. God blesses us with friends!


Page 243 (2016): "The heart is designed to give far more love than the brain can calculate and to endure far more loss than the body anticipates."


Clara is deeply moved by Charles' death. And she loves being outdoors by the trees and in the sunlight. The mix of sad and sweet (and funny) in this story kept me reading.


Page 250 (2016): "Lord, you are so good, and your love holds everything together. Give me joy in every minute I have remaining here in this place you have called me to. If I have any work remaining, please give me wisdom and grace to complete it. Amen."


Clara has "broken out" of the home and is soaking in the natural beauty outdoors. Her prayer is one of willingness (even wanting) to serve, rather than anything for herself. What a woman!


Page 293: She trusted the muted words overflowing from her lips floated across the room, slipped between the grains of the windowpane, and flew upward on the streams of the wind, where they morphed into a great shout and sailed straight to the ears of heaven. Loud, soft, or silent, all praise was heard by the Lord. 

'My lips will glorify you because your faithful love is better than life.' Psalm 63:3"


I love that Clara had a theme verse! I love that she lived out the glorifying the Lord on a regular basis! Before I forget, Jimmy, the teenager who worked at the nursing home, was a fantastic character. What an incredible young man!


Page 306 (2016): "Would Aidyn remain teachable? Would she grow in wisdom and stature and in favor with God and people? Would she stay on the narrow path to heaven? And the biggest question of all: Had Clara loved her enough?"


Again, I love that Clara was thinking of others as she was preparing to go into Eternity. God first, others second. I want to live like that!


Page 308 (2016): Psalm 16:8 "I always let the Lord guide me. Because he is at my right hand, I will not be shaken." 


Clara "gives" Aidyn a life verse just as Martha had given her Psalm 63:3. I love that she has her repeat it over and over and asks her how she will deal with future situations. My NIV has "I keep my eyes always on the Lord. With him at my right hand, I will not be shaken." I think I like Clara's Bible version better. I love that Aidyn admits that she hasn't been reading her Bible much lately and Clara helps her see why she should get back into Scripture as a habit. (It's a good reminder for me, too!)


Page 324 (2016): "How odd it must have been to walk through those sliding glass doors knowing she would never come back out. How hard it must have been to leave behind her old life - her home, her lifestyle, her relationships - and come to this strange place with only some personal items and two white storage boxes, as if she herself was a kind of refugee. 

How difficult it must have been to know that the people she came to live among were not long for the world, and neither was she."


Aidyn is starting to realize the truth of Clara's life, both in the past and now in the present. I was crying off and on from Charles' death to the end of the book. The VR headset scene, the reconciliation of Aidyn's friendship with Rahmiya, the contacts in Thailand, . . . Oh my. This book is good. I don't know that I've read any of Brunsvold's other books, but I may need to request some!


<Above published 5.30.2023. Below added 9.8.2025.>


I wanted to have an ebook on my phone for times when I just wanted to read. I highlighted SO MANY parts! Seriously, I think I need to just buy this for myself. I cried in more than one place. I love this book and may need to write a note to the author thanking her.

A Night Divided

by Jennifer A. Nielsen

Scott County Library paperback 317 pages, plus extras (author interview, notes, timeline, etc.)

Published: 2015

Genre: YA historical fiction (Berlin wall, Cold War)


I read bits and pieces of this when I was subbing in sixth grade a few weeks ago and decided I wanted to read the whole book. It was well written and I am interested in reading other Nielsen titles. 


Gerta and her brother Fritz are in East Berlin with their mother when the wall goes up overnight on August 13, 1961. Her father and brother Dominic are in the West.


I loved the quotations at the start of each chapter. I liked the characters and the story development.


Page 42: "It was wise advice, though I never could stop my thoughts from coming. They just did, all the time. Maybe I wasn't trying hard enough to stop them. I knew I wasn't."


When her friend Anna tells her not to ask or even think questions about wanting to go to the West, Gerta knows that her mind is not going to stop. Our minds are so powerful! It makes me wonder at how people can convince themselves to be brainwashed. The questions of those who wanted to get out of East Berlin make so much sense! If the East is superior, why are we fenced in and not allowed to leave?


Page 67: "I felt like a disease. Just as my father had infected me, I could now infect others. But with what? Courage to speak out? To act? To think and question and believe what I wanted to believe? Somehow I lived in a world where these were bad things."


When Anna tells Gerta she can no longer be her friend, I know it's because of the intimidation of the secret police. How sad it would be to live in a time and a place which makes you question every word, thought, and action. 


Page 105: ". . . it was far too dangerous for me to dig. Because every centimeter I clawed in there put me one step farther inside the Death Strip. If I went too far, I'd - . . . If I went too far, I'd end up in the west. The truth crashed into me like I'd just tumbled through waves of the ocean."


I love when she had the realization of what her dad had tried to communicate about digging! 


Page 188: "'What about the people who want to hold those guns?' I asked.

'I don't pray for them,' he said. 'I can't.'

And I decided in that very same moment that I would. Somebody had to."


I love when Fritz and Gerta were able to have conversations about life and their plans. What a great brother and sister team they were! There was plenty of conflict between them, but also teamwork.


Page 190: "Some people use capitalism to help themselves and let the rest suffer for it."


It's interesting in talking about communism, socialism, capitalism, etc. . . . the reasons people have for doing what they do matters. Some capitalists are greedy and uncaring. Others are more interested in the greater good. Fritz is holding Gerta accountable for her motivations and actions. To be fair, she is young, hungry, and wishing for a better life!

Rubyfruit Jungle

by: Rita Mae Brown

Libby audiobook 6 hours

Read by: Anna Paquin

Published: 1973 (this version in 2022)

Genre: realistic fiction


I did not like this book, but I listened to the entire thing. (I drove from home to Green Bay, WI, and from there to the lake.) The intro alone made me question the content. I had originally checked it out based upon a recommendation from a friend (though she was telling me to read the Sneaky Pie Brown series . . . by this same author).

 

Molly was born in 1944(?) so the story starts with her childhood in the early 50s.


Some quick car notes:

  • Part One:
  • edgy . . . language (swearing and crudity)
  • Molly and Brockle . . . Detweiler - showing his uncircumcized penis for 5 cents per view (as elementary school children
  • "mom" Carrie is nasty
  • cousin Leroy, tattler Earl, Molly is MEAN but Carrie is worse!
  • trivializing marriage, Christian faith, . . 
  • sixth grade, 11 y.o. Molly and Liota exploring one another sensually 
  • Part Two:
  • move to Florida
  • "queer"
  • "Keep doing it if it feels good."
  • Connie, Caroline - negative peer pressure
  • F-bombs galore . . . 
  • devaluing sex, relationships
  • college roommate Faye / psych ward, scholarships removed
  • Part Three:
  • 1960s, home, hitchhiking, NYC
  • Ronny - throwing grapefruits
  • $62.50/month for rent in a NY apartment!!!?? 1962 seems unreal in this regard . . . 
  • convo with Holly re: money, morals, race, etc. I found this part to be ho-hum
  • Holly leaves
  • Part Four:
  • Silver Publishing, Stella, Mr. Cohen
  • Paulina and Paul . . . yuk
  • "incest doesn't seem like such a trauma to me" 
  • and Alice! This was too much for me. Molly is having sex with the mom, the dad, and the daughter. Just no.
  • film school and sexism, equipment, professor 

 

This isn't actually a review, is it? There were places in the book that had beautiful language. I loved Molly's final film school project. I think Carrie was suffering from some serious mental illness. I'm glad we got to revisit Leroy and where life took him. I did not enjoy this book.


Oh! And the title refers to a woman's genitals.

Wishtree

by Katherine Applegate

Libby audiobook 3 hours

Read by: Nancy Linari

Published: 2017

Genre: YA . . . mostly realistic

 

The narrator is a tree (hence the "mostly" realistic) who has been around for 216 rings. Red offers up science lessons and life lessons. 

 

I mostly enjoyed this book because of the humor but also because of the theme of kindness and friendship. The humor (to me) was in the animals' naming system. The skunks all had names of things that smelled wonderful like Fresh Baked Bread, Rose Petals, etc.  The opossums were named after things that frightened them like Hairy Spiders, Flashlight, etc. The owls and crows had different naming systems. And the raccoons were all You. You, You, You, and You didn't always get along with the other animals.


The Muslim family who has moved into the little blue house have received some hateful messages from others in this community. Samar, the little girl, loves to sit by the Wishtree and have the animal babies come to her and sit with her. Her wish is to have a friend. Her neighbor Steven is kind, but it takes the Wishtree and Bongo the crow to get them to become friends.


I jotted a few notes somewhere, but I'm too lazy to go look for them. I enjoyed this story, but it wasn't a "must read" for me. (Wonder by Palacio is a "must read.")

Friday, May 26, 2023

Miss Marple in A Murder Is Announced

by Agatha Christie

Libby audiobook 2 hours

read by: full cast

Published: 1950 (this version 2010)

Genre: murder mystery

 

I had to wait quite a long time for this one! It's classic Christie - lots of characters, lots of clues. I really enjoy Miss Marple. The cast was good.

 

Dora - old classmate, seems spacey but is actually pretty aware

Leticia / Letty and Charlotte / Lottie - sisters with an interesting history . . . 

Bunch and her husband, a member of the clergy (hosting Miss Marple, of course)

Mitzi - the foreign housekeeper with a penchant for histrionics

Lots and lots and lots of other characters. Three or four murders. Switched identities (Pip and Emma?!) and so much more. 

 

Classic Christie. I'm surprised I haven't seen this in print before.

Sunday, May 21, 2023

The Secret Keepers of Old Depot Grocery

by Amanda Cox

Scott County Library paperback 313 pages

Published: 2021

Genre: Christian historical fiction


Back cover blurb: "Present Day. After tragedy plunges her into grief and unresolved anger, Sarah Ashby returns to her childhood home determined to finally follow her long-denied dream of running Old Depot Grocery alongside her mother and grandmother. But when she arrives, her mother, Rosemary, announces to her that the store is closing. Sarah and her grandmother, Glory Ann, make a pact to save the store, but Rosemary has worked her entire life to make sure her daughter never follows in her footsteps. She has her reasons--but she'll certainly never reveal the real one.

1965. Glory Ann confesses to her family that she's pregnant with her deceased fiancé's baby. Pressured into a marriage of convenience with a shopkeeper to preserve the family reputation, Glory Ann vows never to love again. But some promises are not as easily kept as she imagined.

This dual-timeline story from Amanda Cox deftly explores the complexity of a mother-daughter dynamic, the way the secrets we keep shape our lives and the lives of others, and the healing power of telling the truth."

 

I liked this book, but didn't love it. It kept me engaged as a reader to find out how the characters resolve their stories. Glory Ann, Sarah, and Clay were my favorite characters. We'll discuss this at book club tomorrow night (5/22/2023).

 

Page 51: "Most wouldn't consider him classically handsome, but she had witnessed firsthand the selfless way he loved, and he'd become so incredibly beautiful to her."

 

This is referring to Clarence and Glory Ann. Some people don't like referring to males as "beautiful," but I think it fits so well. Clarence was a beautiful human being - gentle, honest, loving, loyal. He was such a good man! (So what that he wasn't really good looking.)

 

Page 51: "'Then what do we have to fear? Tell me what troubles you. It's the things we don't say that have the power to rule our lives without our permission.'"

 

Clarence, again, being wise and compassionate as he talks to Glory Ann.  Expressing our fears and concerns can be a powerful first step toward resolving them.


Page 109: "Glory Ann offered up a quick prayer for Mable as she straightened the newspaper stack. She didn't mind the idea of growing older one bit. It was a privilege to see this much life. But the thought of losing her memories? That was a beast she couldn't fathom facing."


I value being able to remember and think. My mom's dementia really took a toll on her, especially as she knew she was losing the ability to think clearly and remember. I agree with Glory Ann here!


Page 121: 'Maybe you and Aaron both made mistakes you can't undo, but you still have breath in your lungs and life to live. You have the chance for that fresh start you're craving. And you don't have to feel guilty about that. I've learned the hard way that punishing yourself doesn't help anyone.'"


Here Clay is giving life advice to Sarah. It was the idea of "punishing yourself" that caught my attention. I think we can be incredibly hard on ourselves sometimes. Grace is grace, and we all need it.


Page 125: "'The Good Book has a lot to say about giving. And about avoiding the bread of a selfish man. Old Depot Grocery isn't the selfish man of Proverbs. We don't give and lord it over people, forcing them to vomit it out for all to see what we gave them. We don't give store credit with the perspective of a lender. We give. And if it so happens they repay, we count it a blessing. I give carefully, Rosemary, as I can afford to do so. It might mean less lining my pockets, but my heart is fuller for it.'"


Clarence (in the past) taught Glory Ann so much by his words and actions about what it meant to follow Jesus!


Page 156: "Her grandparents were old and bent. Their expressions perpetually a bit resigned. Not at all how she'd pictured them based on Mom's sparse descriptions. Of how rigid and unyielding they were. Maybe that was true at one point, but now it appeared the years had not been kind. Or perhaps it was they who had not been kind to the years."


I disliked Glory Ann's mom and dad from the get-go. And the more I learned about them, the more I disliked them. They had some valid concerns, but did NOT deal with hard issues in a loving, Christ-like manner. They were awful! (The passage is from adult Rosemary going to visit them.)


Page 162:     Lord, make me an instrument of your peace,

                    Where there is hatred, let me sow love;

                    Where there is injury, pardon;

                    Where there is doubt, faith;

                    Where there is despair, hope; 

                    Where there is darkness, light;

                    Where there is sadness, joy.

                    O Divine Master,

                    Grant that I may not so much seek

                    To be consoled as to console;

                    To be understood as to understand;

                    To be loved as to love.

                    For it is in giving that we receive;

                    It is in pardoning that we are pardoned; 

                    And it is in dying that we are born to eternal life.


I have heard this prayer before, but it truly is a beautiful one. Reading it made me want to linger over the words, pray it, and savor it. Glory Ann is praying this as she ponders the future after Clarence has been murdered by a robber at the store.


Page 179: Rosemary finds a letter addressed to her mother and opens it! It's from a man named Jimmy and she is horrified by what she assumes the letter means. So she hides it from her mother. Ugh! I hate this! Secrets and misunderstandings are the basis of this book, but the cost of heartbreak is too high!


Page 189: "Call me anytime you are tempted to freak out about bringing a new life into this crazy ol' world. I've got your back."

 

Libby is such a delightful character. She is just the kind of person Sarah needed to reconnect with as her life changes dramatically. I like that Rosemary had Connie (?) the travel agent friend and Glory Ann had her friends (the poker and prayer group).

 

Page  210: "'Because you are drawn to the way the stories of the past help you make sense of the present.'"

 

Clay is observant and sees Sarah's love of memoirs, reality shows, etc. She is a very story-driven person.

 

Page 261: "I had been a good person who just wanted to make the world a better place, but I'd become so tainted by darkness I couldn't feel the warmth of the sun anymore. And while I was praying, it was like this calm came over me. Even though it was dead silent during that dark night, it was like I heard the words, 'It's not too late.'"


Jimmy sharing his life and what Vietnam did to him . . . powerful.


Page 295: "Thought I'd get a spanking for sure when I told them I did it on purpose, but they prayed with me instead and told me about the importance of confessing and repenting for the wrong I'd done."

(Adult Jessamine telling adult Rosemary that she had found BOTH their parents gluing together the little ceramic dog that had been given to Rosemary as a child.)


How could Clarence and Glory Ann have been so thoughtful and thorough with teaching Jessie life's important lessons (helping her to become a happy, healthy adult) and have missed the mark so much with Rosemary? I honestly didn't like Rosemary very much as a character. She spends her entire adult life playing the role of miserable martyr, which doesn't help anyone!

 

Page 296: "Live, Rosemary. Do the things you want to do. That can mean staying here in Brighton and never leaving. Or it can mean seeing the whole world. Living is about seeing past the challenges and not letting fear or false guilt be the decider for your life. Listen to the passions in your heart that your Creator put there. Maybe it's to stay. Maybe it's to go. Just listen for once instead of coming up with a list of reasons why you can't."

 

You tell her, Jessie!

 

Page 312: The wedding. The misleading info. Duh. Why?

 

Faves: Most of the men, but especially Clay. Jimmy. Sarah's resolve to do things differently. Glory Ann's attitude.

 

Least Fave: Rosemary. Glory Ann's parents. The lame ending.




 

Tuesday, May 16, 2023

Where Is God When It Hurts

by Philip Yancey

Hennepin County Library hardcover 183 pages

Published: 1977

Genre: Christian theology

 

Ugh! This was due a week ago and I've had too many books to read. I have vacillated between hurrying to finish it, buy a copy, or . . . return it and request it again. I've decided on the last one. I'm trying to NOT buy things that I don't NEED. But this book is worth a read!

 

When I was a teen struggling with the idea of faith, I had questions about how a good God allowed so much suffering and evil. Someone recommended a book that I bought and read . . . and had even more questions after! (If you're curious, it was Rabbi Kushner's When Bad Things Happen to Good People.)

 

This book is what I needed four decades ago!

 

I've marked a few spots, but need to finish this entry later after I've finished the book.


Page 44: "The more you coddle children, he says, the more you set them up for an insulated, sensation-starved life." 


Yancey is referring to Dr. Brand, the man who spent his life working with lepers (rather, people with Hansen's Disease). Some parents seek to shield their children from any and every unpleasantness in life. But life is full of pain - physical, emotional, social - and it's helpful to learn how to deal with it while young.


Page 52: "And these are the people who raise the question 'Where is God when it hurts?' most shrilly. If our faith cannot answer them, then we have nothing to say to a broken world."


I like the way Yancey confronts his fellow Christians head on. As believers, we *should* be able to talk with people about God's role in their lives. That said, it was hard to read some of the "Christian" responses to people's suffering. Some of the insensitive platitudes do little to show the love and compassion of Christ. Ouch!


Page 57: "Pain, God's megaphone, can drive me away from Him. I can hate God for allowing such misery. Or, on the other hand, it can drive me to Him. I can believe Him when He says this world is not all there is, and take the chance that He is making a perfect place for those who follow Him on pain-wracked earth."


I forget sometimes that this (earth) is NOT my home! It's very liberating to remember that there's an eternity (pain-free, anger-free) waiting for me after this life.


Page 73: "We make faith not an attitude of trust in something unseen but a route to get something seen - something magical and stupendous, like a miracle or supernatural gift. Faith includes the supernatural, but it also includes daily, dependent trust in spite of results. True faith implies a belief without solid proof - the evidence of things not seen, the substance of things hoped for. God is not mere magic."


Yancey is referring to healing. While it is exciting to celebrate God's healing power, it can certainly leave those who believe and are NOT physically healed feeling discouraged.


I didn't finish chapter 6 because my to-do list exceed my allowed time. I am on page 75 (almost to part 2). 10.6.22


<Above started on 10.6.22. Below added on 5.16.23.>


It's overdue again, but at least I've finished it! Actually, I re-read from the beginning and I have a LOT more post-its in there. (Yes, I should probably just buy my own copy, but I didn't.) I may not add commentary, but these passages really spoke to me.


Page 14: "Why was Claudia moaning in a hospital bed while I stood beside her, healthy? What new words of Christian advice could I add? Something inside me recoiled as I heard the cliched comments to sufferers floating through the hospital corridors. Is Christianity supposed to confuse the sufferer or, rather, help him?"


This situation led to Yancey researching and writing this book. His conversational style makes me feel as though we're chatting about these issues.


Page 16: "'You never know how much you really believe anything until its truth or falsehood becomes a matter of life and death to you.'"


This quote from C.S. Lewis reflects the pain he went through seeing his beloved wife suffer from bone cancer.


Page 38: "Examples of 'painless hell' are numerous and tragic. They should make all of us discard the common notion that pain is an unpleasantness to be avoided at all costs. Generally, pain does not dampen life. More than anything, it frees us to enjoy normalcy on this planet. Without it, we would lead unbalanced, paranoid lives, encountering unknown dangers, never confident that we weren't destroying ourselves."


Page 44 - I marked the line about coddling children again. Being protective and being overprotective result in very different kinds of people. Getting the balance right is important and not always easy! But parents should NOT try to shield children from every unpleasantness. Life needs to be dealt with!


Page 52: "Later in this book you will meet people with broken spinal cords and Jewish survivors of the Holocaust. These are the people we must face head-on. No amount of mushy rationalizing can resolve their piercing question 'Where is God when it hurts?' most shrilly. If our faith cannot answer them, then we have nothing to say to a broken world."


Wow. He doesn't pull punches. And I love the title of this book . . . 


Page 57: "I had often called myself an optimist, to avoid the too evident blasphemy of pessimism. But all the optimism of the age had been false and disheartening for this reason, that it had always been trying to prove that we fit in to the world. The Christian optimism is based on the fact that we do not fit in to the world."


This quotation from G.K. Chesterton is a great reminder that believers are NOT at home on Earth. Our home is waiting for us in Heaven. Eternity is a long time!


Page 63: "If you believe in a world of chance, what difference does it make whether Yuba City's bus or Salina's bus crashes? But if you believe in a world ruled by a powerful God who loves you tenderly - then it makes an awful difference. . . . Posing the questions may sound sacrilegious. But they've haunted me and other Christians I know. And they've been tossed at me like spears by scoffing friends."


His reference to the Yuba City bus is based on a 1976 accident that killed 29 choir students. Grief, sorrow, loss, pain . . . people wonder if it's God's punishment, or conversely why he allowed it to happen. This is the crux of this book - why?

 

Page 65: "The New Testament, however, seems to pull away from the Old Testament pattern of reward / punishment, possibly because of a shift in God's manner of acting in the world."

 

Yancey is referring to the difference that Jesus Christ makes. 

 

Page 67: "Maybe God isn't trying to tell us anything specific each time we hurt. Pain and suffering are part and parcel of our planet, and Christians are not exempt. Half the time we know why we get sick: too little exercise, a poor diet, contact with a germ. Do we really expect God to go around protecting us whenever we encounter something dangerous?"

 

Page 69: "God wants us to freely choose to love Him, even when that choice involves pain - because we are committed to Him, not to our own good feelings and rewards. He wants us to cleave to Him, as Job did, even when we have every reason to hotly deny Him."

 

Page 73: "A sick person is not unspiritual. The Bible does not pretend that a Christian should expect life to be easier, more antiseptic, or safer than for a non-Christian."

 

Page 86: "'Pain turned you to God' - in my view, this is probably the most accurate, succinct summary of the role of suffering.It blends with the Bible's tone of emphasizing the Christian's response, not the cause of the suffering."


Yancey quotes from 2 Corinthians 7:8-11. (Read it. Good stuff!)


Page 90: "God does not need our good responses for Himself, to satisfy some parental hunger. He focuses attention on our response, I believe, for our sakes, not His. Would it help our condition to know exactly why God is permitting our suffering? Such knowledge may engender even more bitterness. But it does help our condition when God asks us to turn to Him. It can break down our self-sufficiency and create in us a profound new sense of faith in God. And, it can produce changes of lasting value inside us."


Yes! We need God, even when we think we're self-sufficient! The more we think we're in control, the harder life gets.


Page 97: "'God did not rescue me and make my suffering easier. He simply proved to me that He was still alive, and He still knew I was here. We Christians drew together . . . . I can only speak for myself. Others turned from God because of Dachau. Who am I to judge them? I simply know that God met me. For me, He was enough, even at Dachau.'"


I have no idea how my faith might sustain me if I were ever in such a horrible situation. I want to build up my faith and memorize God's Word so that I am ready if ever tested! This quotation is from Christian Reger, a pastor who was rounded up by the Nazis. His physical and spiritual health were at stake.


Page 104: "Yet he also know that his faith in God couldn't be a bargain: 'You heal me, God, and I'll believe.' He had to believe because God was worthy of his faith. He took that risk and committed his life to Jesus Christ."


This chapter is about Brian Sternberg, an athlete who broke his spinal cord in a 1963 training accident. He and his parents were confident that God could heal him completely (and that's what they prayed and hoped for). I had to Google him to find out what happened . . .  I like this example of knowing that we don't "bargain" with God. Our prayers are part of our relationship with Him.


Page 137: "Medical scientists are discovering that our attitude about a particular pain is one of the chief factors in intensifying its effects."


Yes! Attitude matters a lot! This chapter dealt with things that can make pain seem much worse, including fear and helplessness.


Page 142: "Strong feelings of fear or helplessness not only worsen a sick patient's condition, they actually may make healthy people more susceptible to illness."


Page 143: "A warning, then, to any person facing prolonged illness, is to look for ways to avoid feelings of helplessness."


Page 146: "A majority of people turned to God with a dramatic prayer. Church attendance swelled to record numbers, but within a year it had dropped back to normal."


Here he's referring to a 1964 earthquake in Alaska. It's a really interesting chapter. But this one line reminded me of people turning to churches after 9/11 . . . then fading away. We go to God in crisis, but don't want to commit to a long-term relationship with him. Complacency and selfishness . . . .


Page 149: "Sufferings can become a trap for self-pity, wounded pride, martyr feelings, and a negative self-image. Other people can represent the only way to help a person climb out of his helpless despair."


He goes on to talk about how happy success stories can be overemphasized. (Think Chicken Soup for the Soul resolutions . . . ) This made me think of the phrase "toxic positivity." I don't want to be guilty of lacking compassion for others' suffering. (But I definitely thought about people I know when I read the excerpt above. Some people definitely seem to thrive on sharing their sufferings and misery.)


Page 155: "'I think God has planned the strength and beauty of youth to be physical. But the strength and beauty of age is spiritual. We gradually lose the strength and beauty that is temporary so we'll be sure to concentrate on the strength and beauty which is forever. And so we'll be eager to leave the temporary, deteriorating part of us and be truly homesick for our eternal home. If we stayed young and strong and beautiful, we might never want to leave!'"


I love this! Yes, we age and weaken and have more physical problems. God designed us to go home to Him with new bodies!


Page 160: "The scene, with the sharp spikes and bleeding death and wrenching thud as the cross was dropped in the ground, has been told so often, that we, who shrink from a news story on the death of a race horse or of baby seals, flinch not at all at its retelling. It was a bloody death, an execution quite unlike the quick, sterile ones we know today - gas chambers, electric chairs, hangings. This one stretched on for hours in front of a jeering crowd."


Reading this made me think of the teen who watched The Passion of the Christ when it came out and said it was no big deal. We have become desensitized to violence in our culture.

 

Page 170: ". . . Do we listen to them, hear them, respond? Or do we, through numbness, allow them to self-destruct, sacrificing a limb of the body of Christ? The screams of pain are not always so far away: there are some in every church and office. The unemployed, divorced, widowed, bedridden, aged . . . are we listening to them? The Christian church, by all accounts, has done a mediocre job of acting as Christ's body through the ages. Sometimes it has seemed to devour itself (the Inquisition, religious wars). Yet Christ, committed to human freedom, still relies upon us to flesh out His will in the world, empowered by the Holy Spirit."

 

Again, I love that Yancey is straightforward. The body of Christ needs to wake up! We have a job to do.


Page 171: "Bear one another's burdens, the Bible says. It is a lesson about pain that we all can agree to. Some of us will not see pain as a gift; some will always accuse God of being unfair for allowing it. But, the fact is, pain and suffering are here among us, and we need to respond. The response Jesus showed was to bear the burdens of those He touched."


I want to live out my life in faith as a genuine disciple of Jesus Christ.


Page 173: "Christ brought us the possibility of an afterlife without pain and suffering. All our hurts, then, are temporary. Our future will be painless. Today, we are almost embarrassed to talk about belief in an afterlife . . . "


Thank you, Jesus. Help me to not be embarrassed to talk about my hope and your promises.


Page 181: "As I visited those whose pain far exceeded my own, though, I was surprised by its effects. Suffering was as likely to produce strengthened faith as to sow agnosticism. . . . In one sense, there will be no solution to pain until Jesus returns and recreates the earth. I am sustained by faith in that great hope."


I'm glad I read this. I need to return it to the library so others can read it! And perhaps I'll end up buying myself a copy anyhow . . .



Sunday, May 14, 2023

The Magician's Nephew

 by C.S. Lewis

Libby audiobook 4 hours

read by: Kenneth Branagh

Published: 1955 (this version in 2005)

Genre: children's fantasy fiction


I have read this book before in print, but hadn't read it for quite a while. I like having audiobooks on my phone, especially for drive time. I didn't realize until just now (getting ready to blog it), that Kenneth Branagh was the narrator! I almost want to get it again and re-listen . . . 


I knew this was the Narnia "origin" story, but I didn't remember the details. (It's possible that more than twenty years have passed since I last read the book.) Uncle Andrew is a completely selfish jerk. Polly and Diggory are curious children. I liked the description of the "between" world. I really liked when they saw the guinea pig there!

 

The magic rings that transport them from world to world is an interesting device. (Lewis and Tolkien were contemporaries . . . )


The children going through the empty attic crawlspaces - such a kid thing to do!


The witch. Aslan. The animals. I had forgotten about Strawberry's master and his wife coming to be in Narnia. 


I very much enjoyed listening to this story.

Tuesday, May 02, 2023

The Girl Who Drank the Moon

by Kelly Barnhill

Libby eBook 500 or so pages

Published: 2016

Genre: YA fantasy


This book surprised me. I didn't care for it at first, but the characters drew me in.


Xan, the elderly witch who rescues the babies abandoned by The Protectorate each year.

Glerk, the ancient bog monster poet

Fyrian, the tiny dragon who thinks he's Simply Enormous

Antain, the kind-hearted young man who wants to be a carpenter

The madwoman . . . 

And of course, Luna, the title character (though she's the one it took me a while to like!)


Chapter 5 (Glerk) - "She is being adorable as some sort of hideous ruse, to spite me. What a mean baby!"


I love how he falls in love with Luna against his better judgment. He is so sweet!


Chapter 5 (narrator) - "Even when Luna was content, she still was not quiet. She hummed; she gurgled; she babbled; she screeched; she guffawed; she snorted; she yelled. She was a waterfall of sound, pouring, pouring, pouring."


That is so true of babies!


Chapter 7 (Xan) - "Memory was a slippery thing - slick moss on an unstable slope - and it was ever so easy to lose one's footing and fall."


The whole theme of memories and forgetting . . . that wasn't my favorite aspect of the book. But I love the language the author uses.


Chapter 8 (storyteller) - "But he didn't kill the Witch. The Witch killed him instead. This is why it doesn't pay to be brave."


I wasn't entirely sure who was telling the story in each storytelling part, but the stories definitely helped fill in some of the legend aspects. The idea that the moral of the story is that "it doesn't pay to be brave" made me laugh.


Chapter 9 (Xan's perspective) - "When Zosimos rescued her and bound her to his allegiance and care, she was so grateful that she was ready to follow any rule in the world. Not so with Luna. She was only five. And remarkably bullheaded."


Oh my! To love and try to teach a small child, especially one who is overflowing with magic and exuberance . . . a distinct challenge!


Chapter 13 (Sister Ignatia) - "Sister Ignacia laughed. 'Oh, sweet Antain! There is no cure for sorrow.' Her lips unfurled into a wide smile, as though this was most excellent news."


She was so clearly evil! It was interesting how the author let us know more about the characters with each successive chapter. The concept of sorrow and how it impacts people was another interesting theme in this story.


Chapter 17 (Luna) - "She loved the moon so much, she wanted to wrap her arms around it and sing to it. She wanted to gather every morsel of moonlight into a great bowl and drink it dry. She had a hungry mind, an itchy curiosity, and a knack for drawing, building, and fashioning."


I do love that Luna was eager and curious. The idea of drinking moonlight is interesting.


Chapter 39 (Luna, about Xan) - "Was love a compass? Luna's mind was pulled to her grandmother's mind. Was knowledge a magnet?"


The idea of love being a compass appeals to me. Love is a powerful force!


Chapter 41 (Xan) - "Everything you see is in the process of making or unmaking or dying or living. Everything is in a state of change."


This is so true, but not a truth that we think about often. I'm often uncomfortable with change, yet it is a constant in life.


Chapter 46 (Luna) - "'Like you, I was brought to a family who loved me and whom I love. I cannot stop loving that family, and I don't want to. I can only allow my love to increase.' She smiled. 'I love the grandmother who raised me. I love the mother I lost. My love is boundless. My heart is infinite. And my joy expands and expands. You'll see."


The ending of the story was very satisfying. I see why this book has won so many awards!